Back to the journal

Why Vessel Strikes Are Difficult to Detect in Coastal Waters

Distant ship crossing coastal waters

A vessel strike can go unnoticed if the whale is underwater, the contact is out of sight or the crew cannot identify what happened. An injured whale can swim away, and a whale that dies may sink, drift offshore or reach a shore where nobody reports it. Even if a carcass is found, its condition can limit what an examination reveals. For those reasons, a list of confirmed whale strikes in coastal British Columbia describes cases that produced enough evidence to document. Scientists use other methods to study the risk that the incident record may miss. DFO Pacific marine mammal management framework US Marine Mammal Commission overview of large whale vessel strikes Research on modelling vessel strike risk in British Columbia

From a shore viewpoint or boat near Campbell River, a whale can appear for a few seconds and disappear below the surface again. An observer may be watching the blow while the vessel’s bow is somewhere else. Another person may see the vessel pass and have no view of the whale at all. Those separate vantage points help explain why reconstructing an incident takes more than knowing that a whale and vessel were in the same general area.

The moment of contact may be hidden

A whale spends much of its time below the surface. A person on the vessel may see a surfacing before or after contact and miss the point where it happened. From a large vessel, the area immediately around the hull can be difficult to see. From farther away, waves and distance can hide the interaction. Crew or passengers may hear or feel something without knowing the cause. In an incident report, it matters whether someone actually saw contact and which parts were inferred from the sequence. NOAA Fisheries vessel strike overview US Marine Mammal Commission vessel strike overview

Picture two observations a minute apart. A person on shore sees a blow near a vessel’s path. Later, a passenger sees a whale at the stern. The sequence places a whale near the vessel during that period. It leaves open whether the vessel touched it, whether the views show the same animal and what happened underwater. If the passenger also saw the hull make contact, that is an additional piece of evidence. The time and location of each observation help a responder compare them.

A direct report also depends on someone recognising what they saw and knowing where to send it. A report made while the event is fresh can contain details that are difficult to reconstruct later. If the animal moves out of view, the last position and direction may matter more than a guess about its eventual destination. Fisheries and Oceans Canada provides reporting routes for accidents and for animals in distress. DFO marine mammal incident and accidental contact reporting

An injured whale can leave the area

Some injuries can be conspicuous at the surface. Others can be below the waterline or internal. A whale may continue moving and become difficult to find again. A photo from an ordinary sighting can document a mark, but a mark by itself may be hard to date or attribute. A clear series of images and a previous record of the same individual can give investigators a stronger basis for deciding when a visible change appeared. The evidence still has to fit the possible causes of the injury.

If an injured animal is observed days later, there may be no direct connection between the place where it is seen and the place where the injury occurred. An animal can travel after contact. Its behaviour can also change for other reasons. A report describing an obvious wound, the time and the animal’s last known position helps responders assess the situation. The report can preserve uncertainty about the cause without losing the details that were visible.

In a monitoring database, a whale with a suspicious mark and a directly witnessed collision can appear in different categories. The first is a record of the animal’s condition. The second supplies evidence of contact. A count that combines them answers a different question from a count restricted to confirmed cases. When reading a summary, check how the authors defined a strike and which kinds of evidence were accepted.

A carcass can be missed before anyone can examine it

If a whale dies, it can sink or drift. Currents and wind can move a floating carcass away from the point where the animal died. It may reach an isolated shore or remain offshore. A carcass reported on a beach gives investigators a starting point for examination, but the find location and the incident location can be different. NOAA’s large whale ship strike database describes these limits in interpreting strandings and carcass records. NOAA technical report on large whale ship strike records

Survey effort also affects what is found. A shore near a community can have many people who might see a carcass, while a remote inlet may be visited far less often. A floating whale can pass outside commonly travelled routes. A study in the northern Gulf of Mexico estimated low carcass detection for several cetacean species and explained why analytical methods matter for mortality that is rarely observed. The study’s estimates describe that region and its data. They illustrate a detection problem without supplying a British Columbia correction factor. Williams and colleagues, research on cetacean carcass detection

Imagine two years with the same number of deaths but different search effort. In the first, only a few beaches are visited. In the second, survey coverage increases and more carcasses are reported. The record can rise even if the underlying deaths did not. Different drift conditions can have a similar effect by bringing more carcasses within sight. An apparent trend in findings is worth investigating with information about search coverage, current and the condition of the remains.

An examination has limits too

A veterinary post-mortem examination, or necropsy, can document injuries and help assess how they occurred. Investigators may look for blunt trauma, fractures or wounds consistent with contact. They also need evidence about timing. A carcass can sustain damage after death, including contact with a vessel, and injuries can be difficult to interpret once tissues have decomposed. The findings may support a strike as a cause, leave several possibilities open or be too limited for a conclusion. NOAA Fisheries vessel strike information

Conditions at the site affect what can be examined. A stranded animal may be too remote or unsafe to reach, or parts of the body may be inaccessible. A photo can preserve a visible feature and provide a record of location. It can seldom show everything investigators need to assess internal injuries or distinguish contact before death from later damage. Even a clear picture from the public is one piece of the evidence.

If you read that an examination found a wound “consistent with” a strike, that wording describes how the injury fits the hypothesis. The strength of the conclusion also depends on other findings and on how complete the examination was. A cause can remain undetermined for a whale that was definitely found. That is a separate gap from the animals that were never recovered. A count of examinations, a count of confirmed causes and a count of all strandings therefore need their own denominators.

Why researchers also model risk

A British Columbia study combined information about whale distribution and vessel traffic to estimate spatial patterns of collision risk for fin, humpback and killer whales. The overlap can highlight places where boats and whales are more likely to encounter each other. It provides a way to study risk even where incident reports are sparse. The result depends on the whale surveys, vessel records, area and assumptions the researchers used.

A risk map and an incident map answer different questions. A risk map may identify a channel where both whales and vessels use the same space. An incident map shows cases detected and recorded according to the programme’s criteria. A reported event on a beach may have started elsewhere. A high-risk area can have few confirmed cases when visibility, reporting or carcass recovery is limited. Read the caption or method to see whether the map represents observed events, predicted overlap or an estimate of mortality.

Research on the US West Coast has also used models to estimate mortality from collisions for several large whale species and compared model output with estimates based on recorded strandings and assumptions about detection. These approaches make the missing evidence part of the analysis. The results are tied to the region and model. A reader should keep the time period, species and uncertainty with any estimate quoted from the study. US West Coast modelling study of whale mortality from vessel collisions

Why cases found near shore can look more common

Places with boat traffic, shore access and regular observations are more likely to produce a report of something visible. That can help investigators find incidents quickly. It can also make a concentration of reports difficult to interpret. Some of the pattern may come from actual risk, and some may come from where people and responders can see and examine animals. The two can occur in the same place. A busy route may create more overlap with whales and also provide more witnesses than a remote coast. US Marine Mammal Commission on detection limits

A reader can ask three practical questions about a report. What stretch of coast does it cover? How did people search for or report whales? Which cases could be examined? Those answers help distinguish a lack of records from a stretch that received comparable monitoring and had few confirmed incidents. If the reporting network changed during the period shown, check whether the report explains how those changes affect the comparison. More complete reporting is a change in the evidence available, even when the underlying risk cannot yet be measured.

If a map shows a cluster near a town, check which location was plotted. A whale found by a busy public beach could have come from another part of the coast. A witness report can sometimes locate the actual collision more precisely. A model of risk may use vessel routes and estimated whale distribution rather than either of those points. Comparing the map labels gives a clearer view of how each set of records relates to the water you are looking at.

What to report in British Columbia

If you observe an injured, entangled, stranded or dead marine mammal in BC, keep clear and call the BC Marine Mammal Response Network at 1-800-465-4336. Tell the crew immediately if you are a passenger and think contact occurred. DFO lists Pacific incident contacts and provides guidance for accidental contact reports. Give the time, location, animal description and what happened, making clear which details you actually saw. Do not touch or move the animal.

When you observe a healthy animal, the information has a different purpose. A sighting can add evidence about the animals using an area and the conditions when they were detected. Eagle Eye Adventures’ guide to marine wildlife around Campbell River gives a starting point for recognising some of the species in the same waters. Whether you see a routine surfacing or a possible incident, keep the time, place and exact view with your description. Those details let a reader or responder use the evidence without assuming they saw the parts that were hidden.

In a report, keep the time of the observation separate from any estimate of when an injury occurred.

In a report, keep the time of the observation separate from any estimate of when an injury occurred.