During a Pacific herring spawn, a stretch of British Columbia shoreline can turn milky white or turquoise. The colour comes from milt, the fluid containing sperm that male herring release into the water. Female herring release sticky eggs that settle on eelgrass, seaweed and other submerged surfaces. The pale water may show where spawning is happening, while the eggs below record where it has already taken place. Fisheries and Oceans Canada uses the colour as one cue to locate spawn and collects separate measurements of eggs for its spawn index. DFO Pacific herring profile DFO technical report on the spawn index
From a shoreline viewpoint, the edge of the colour can be surprisingly sharp in one direction and difficult to see in another. If you’re looking into strong sunlight, reflection may hide the pale water completely. From higher ground, the shape of a light band may be easier to pick out. What you see from any one angle depends on the position of the sun, the condition of the surface and where the tide has carried the suspended material since it entered the water.
How spawning changes the water
Pacific herring are schooling fish, and spawning can concentrate many individuals in the same shallow area. As female fish release eggs, the eggs adhere to material below the surface. Males release milt around the spawning fish. When enough milt accumulates in the water, the patch looks cloudy. From above, DFO describes spawn as milky or turquoise, often in bands parallel to shore. The colour need not fill a bay or follow every bit of the shoreline. Spawning can be concentrated over the places with suitable habitat. DFO technical report on identifying spawn
A useful way to picture it is to follow two different parts of the event. Milt disperses in the water, so the visible patch can move, become less distinct and disappear. Eggs adhere to surfaces and remain as they develop. A stretch of pale water and the full extent of egg deposition can therefore have different outlines. The time when a person sees the brightest colour may also differ from the time when a survey team can most readily confirm and measure eggs below.
Imagine you watch from one point while the colour appears to spread sideways along the coast. That movement tells you what the light area was doing during your visit. Part of the change could come from spawning across additional ground, while part could come from the movement and mixing of water. A second viewpoint can help show the shape of the patch. It takes observations of eggs or fish to determine more about exactly where the spawn was laid.
What happens to the eggs
A female herring releases eggs into water where they can attach to underwater material. DFO describes sheltered bays and estuaries as preferred spawning areas, with eelgrass and other submerged vegetation serving as common surfaces. The leaves, fronds and stalks give eggs places to adhere. On suitable habitat, repeated spawning can create a dense coating. How much a particular patch holds depends on the available material and the amount of spawn deposited there. DFO technical report on spawn deposition
From shore, vegetation near the surface may be easier to see in clear water after the colour fades. A lot of eggs can remain underwater, where water depth, ripples and light limit what you see. A submerged bed may also extend much farther than the shallow part you can see from the bank. Those limits explain why looking into a small patch of water from one angle offers only a partial view of where herring spawned.
After development, larvae hatch and enter the water. The visible colour, the deposition of eggs and the presence of young fish refer to different points in the life cycle. A dated photograph of the water can tell you when the plume was visible. A survey of egg deposition can tell you where spawn accumulated and in what amount by a specified measure. A study of young fish asks a later question about development and survival. It’s worth keeping those stages distinct when you read a report or describe what you saw.
When and where the colour can appear
British Columbia herring return to many of the same general areas to spawn, commonly in spring. DFO’s records divide the coast into sections and include observations of spawn in different years. A history of spawning in a section tells you that the event has occurred there. The exact stretches of shoreline, dates and conditions can vary. A day with no colour visible at one viewpoint can coincide with spawning elsewhere or with eggs still on vegetation from an earlier event. Open Government Pacific herring spawn index data and maps
If you’re travelling near Campbell River in spring, decide whether you want a general look at coastal wildlife or hope to recognise signs of a spawn if they appear. The first can be planned around a normal shoreline visit. For the second, a dated, local observation gives better context than an annual calendar. Check when the observation was made and whether it refers to fish, milt or eggs. A photo posted this morning may show an event photographed several days earlier. A place name can also refer to a long reach of shoreline with several different viewing angles.
Different levels of exposure can make an otherwise promising view hard to use. Rough water brightens the tops of waves. Light from a clear sky can tint an entire bay. A pale plume may stand out best where its boundary lies next to darker water under similar light. Remember which way you were facing and whether the tint remained visible when the reflections changed. You can compare notes later with someone who watched from a different side of the bay.
What fisheries scientists measure
Aerial and shoreline observations can help locate areas of spawn. DFO’s technical report also describes surveys that measure egg deposition. Divers can record spawn and the vegetation or other substrate on transects, which are survey lines that sample across the area. The length and width of the deposit and the density of eggs help determine the spawn index. A broad photograph of milky water supplies information about a visible event. The index comes from measurements that have a defined relationship to the eggs that were laid.
Consider two sheltered stretches of coast that both show pale water. In the first, eggs cover a relatively narrow bed densely. In the second, eggs are more spread out across a wider area. The colour of the surface alone would give you little basis for deciding which deposit held more eggs. Survey lines can supply information about the footprint and density together. This is one reason records refer to a survey method and a unit when they describe the size of a spawn.
The open government dataset gives readers access to spawn records and related technical documents. If you open a map or table, start with the area, the year and the column description. Read where observations were collected and whether the map is showing a named section, a survey location or something else. A coastline shaded as part of a geographic section may contain several individual spawning locations. That shape is different from the pale band you would see across the water on a particular day.
Why other wildlife may draw your attention first
Pacific herring are prey for a variety of fish, birds and marine mammals. An aggregation of herring can provide feeding opportunities, and some wildlife also uses the eggs after deposition. If birds gather off a point, you may notice the activity before you can see any change in the water’s colour. Birds feed on several kinds of small fish and other prey. A feeding flock tells you that the birds found something to eat, while an identification of the prey needs its own evidence.
Watch where the activity is in relation to the pale water, shore and tide. If birds are diving farther offshore and a pale area hugs the shore, record them as separate observations. A group of birds can move rapidly while the colour drifts with the water. There may be a connection, and the two things can still occupy different parts of the coast. Eagle Eye Adventures’ guide to wildlife beyond whales around Campbell River introduces other animals to look for along these same shores.
Compare a surface sighting with a confirmed spawn
Picture a pale patch you noticed after a windy afternoon. It lies along a rocky point, and there are gulls farther out. From that view, you have a colour observation and the position of the birds. You may not have seen the fish or any egg deposit. If a fisheries survey later reports herring eggs in the same area at about the same time, the two observations give each other context. If the survey refers to a different shoreline or a different week, keep the records separate until you have a closer match.
The same exercise works when the colour is unmistakable in a photograph. A dated image taken from a hillside can show the shape and extent of the visible plume. It might miss a shallow strip behind a point or show water that has already moved away from the area where fish spawned. When you compare the photo with a technical report, ask which part of the event each source captured. This helps you see why both the spectacular view and the measurements below the surface matter.
Why eggs can turn up on the beach
A frond or strand of eelgrass may break free and wash onto shore carrying eggs. That gives you a chance to see a deposit that was hard to pick out underwater. The strand may have moved since the eggs were laid, and the tide line is where you found it. When you record a photograph, keep those facts separate. Include a wider view that shows where the material lay and a close view of what was attached, if both are possible from the public path or beach.
A patch of eggs on drifting vegetation also differs from a deposit that surveyors can measure in place. The piece on shore gives no ready measure of how much spawning occurred across the bottom. A bed of attached vegetation has a position, width and length that can be sampled. If you read a survey result after seeing eggs ashore, look for which material the survey covered and which unit it reports.
Can you see a spawn without pale water?
Yes. By the time you visit, the pale water can have dispersed even though eggs remain attached below the surface. In another case, you may have a poor view of the water from shore while an observer elsewhere can see it clearly. If you return to a public viewpoint, note the date and direction of the light before comparing the new view with the first. Look from shore without moving through vegetation or disturbing wildlife. A useful record can be as simple as when you were there, what the weather was doing, what part of the coast was visible and whether you saw colour, fish, or a deposit on vegetation.
