Male humpback whales sing long, patterned sequences of sounds. Scientists most often associate these songs with the breeding season, when they may play a role in interactions with other males, prospective mates or both. Researchers have also recorded song along migration routes and in some feeding areas, including off northern British Columbia. A recording can show that song occurred, where a hydrophone detected it and how its structure compares with earlier recordings. Finding out what the song does for the whale is harder. To understand the difference, listen for how the sounds repeat and ask what was happening when the recording was made.
What makes a sound sequence a song?
A humpback song has an organisation that researchers can describe at several scales. A unit is an individual sound. A sequence of units forms a phrase. Repeated related phrases make up a theme, and a succession of themes forms a song. Researchers compare recordings by looking at how those components are arranged and how consistently they recur. A brief clip may contain a recognisable part of the structure even though it cuts off before a complete sequence. North Pacific song analysis from Okinawa
When you hear a recording, try marking the return of a distinctive sound. You might hear it in the same position in several phrases. Then listen for a change to a new phrase, which can indicate a shift to another theme. What sounds like a collection of squeaks, sweeps and pulses at first can become easier to follow once you notice the repetition. Researchers examine both the recording and its visual representation to decide which features to compare.
A sustained recording is especially useful if several whales can be heard at once. One singer’s themes may overlap another animal’s sounds. An abrupt interruption could come from movement, competing noise or the end of a recorded segment. The listener needs enough context to distinguish those changes from the structure of the song itself. A research paper usually describes how recordings were selected and how uncertain sounds were handled.
Why researchers associate song with breeding
Male humpback song is strongly associated with the breeding season and occurs frequently at low-latitude wintering grounds. That seasonal and social setting supports the idea that song has a reproductive role. Researchers have proposed several possibilities. A singer could advertise characteristics to potential mates, interact with other males or influence social spacing. More than one function may be involved. It is difficult to determine which whale was listening and what its response meant. NOAA account of Olympic Coast song research
A scientist investigating one of these ideas needs more than a recording of the singer. The position and behaviour of nearby animals may be relevant. So might their sex, identity or associations, where those details can be established. If another whale approaches while a song is underway, that is evidence of movement during the singing. It does not by itself show that the approach was caused by the song or reveal what either animal gained from it.
Listen for the wording when someone describes a study. “Males sing during the breeding season” describes when the researchers observe the behaviour. “Song attracts mates” is a proposed explanation that takes further evidence to assess. Saying that song is thought to play a role in breeding preserves the connection without promising a complete account of its functions.
How a shared song can change
Males in a breeding area commonly sing broadly similar versions of the song during a given period. Similarity does not require each performance to be identical. Researchers can find changes in the sounds used, the structure of a phrase or the order of themes. A study of songs recorded off Okinawa examined changes across three years and compared themes with published examples from other parts of the North Pacific. Some themes were shared across widely separated areas.
A wider North Pacific study also found shared phrases, temporary regional differences and variable rates of change. The results show why one recording makes a poor permanent reference for a whole population. When you compare clips, note the year as well as the location. A pair of recordings from different places in the same year can help answer a geographic question. A set from one place over several years can show how the song there changed. North Pacific song comparison
Scientists discuss song change as a form of cultural transmission because whales can pick up elements heard from other singers. Song comparisons can help investigate contact among groups. Similarity alone leaves the history of contact uncertain. Whales may have heard each other in an area or season that was poorly covered by recordings. A study can document which phrases were shared and assess explanations for how they spread.
Why other humpback sounds deserve their own category
Humpbacks produce vocalisations besides song. Researchers working in Southeast Alaska documented calls on feeding grounds and compared their characteristics across decades. Some call types were relatively stable across the study period, a different pattern from the progressive changes researchers describe in breeding song. These sounds give scientists another way to examine how humpbacks use sound in social and feeding settings. Research on Southeast Alaska humpback calls
If you hear an unfamiliar sound on a recording, the surrounding sequence is helpful. A repeated call in a feeding encounter may have a different context from a similar sound embedded in a succession of song phrases. One clip can lack the repetitions that would let a listener make that distinction. If you want to compare audio examples, check how the researchers describe the larger recording and the behaviour that accompanied it.
A video of a whale at the surface presents another challenge. The sound might come from the animal in the frame, another whale nearby, wind at the microphone or vessel machinery. Without information on how the sound was recorded and synchronised, the video gives you little basis for assigning a singer. A correctly labelled recording and a description of the observation method make a better starting point.
What hydrophones have detected off British Columbia
A hydrophone is a microphone designed to record underwater sound. Researchers can deploy one to record through darkness and in conditions where visual observations would be difficult. A study of northern British Columbia combined visual and acoustic work and recorded humpback vocalisations at hydrophones on both sides of Gwaii Haanas. The researchers reported a winter peak in acoustic activity associated with song at their west-coast sites. These recordings demonstrate that humpback song can be detected outside the familiar low-latitude breeding grounds. Northern British Columbia acoustic and visual survey
Researchers at the Olympic Coast National Marine Sanctuary have also investigated singing in a feeding area. Hearing song there opens questions about whether it serves a role similar to its role in wintering waters and how singers use it in different conditions. The timing, duration and context of recordings can help narrow those possibilities. It is easier to establish when song was detected than to establish what the singer intended.
A Gwaii Haanas record covers the place where the hydrophone could detect sound and the dates when it was recording. It does not tell you when song will be heard near Campbell River. The study can still help put a local whale encounter in context. British Columbia is part of a broader region where humpbacks can both feed and vocalise, with patterns that differ by site, season and method of observation.
How to interpret a day with no detected song
Start by asking whether equipment was listening and how the recording was made. Researchers have to account for the hours when a device was operating, the noise present and the kinds of sound that could reach it. A whale within the area may have been silent. A singer farther away might have been outside the useful listening range. Comparing detection days across a season makes sense only if you know the methods used to collect and review those recordings.
Even a long recording with repeated songs can leave questions about the number of whales present. One singer may repeat its sequence many times. Several can overlap. Unless there is other evidence about identity or location, the number of songs is a poor shortcut to the number of individuals. Visual observations can provide information about whales at the surface while acoustic data document sound that may have come from animals out of view. A study can use both without treating the two methods as interchangeable.
If you see a chart labelled as the number of days with song, read the units carefully. It may summarise detections across hours or days and include a rule for how much recorded sound counted. A second chart might show the number of identified whales photographed in the same waters. Both charts can tell a story about the area. They answer different questions, and peaks need to be interpreted with the collection methods in mind.
Listen with the Campbell River setting in mind
When you see a humpback on a boat trip, pay attention to the sounds you can identify from the surface, such as the blow as the whale breathes. A blow is part of the surfacing sequence. The song discussed here is usually studied with an underwater recording. You may be able to compare archived audio later and connect it with what your guide explained about seasonal movements and the feeding habitat around Vancouver Island. Eagle Eye’s Campbell River whale watching tour
A worthwhile question for a guide is how a particular sound was identified. If the crew describes a published recording, ask where it was made and whether the researchers called it a song or another vocalisation. The answer helps connect the sound to a documented place and context. When choosing a trip, use the operator’s departure information and expect observations to depend on the whales, route and conditions that day.
Try comparing two labelled recordings
Choose two recordings with dates and study locations. Follow the order of repeated phrases before comparing the pitch or apparent loudness. Loudness may depend partly on how far the whale was from the recording equipment and on how the audio was prepared for playback. A similar sequence of themes is more informative for song comparison than a resemblance between two isolated sounds. If you find a phrase in one clip that you cannot hear in the other, check the lengths of the clips. You may be listening to different parts of a longer sequence. A short excerpt often omits the transition between themes.
Frequently asked questions
Do all humpbacks sing?
The structured song discussed here is associated with male humpbacks. Humpbacks also produce other vocalisations, and hearing one sound alone may give too little information to tell whether it belongs to a song.
Are humpback songs the same every year?
Songs can change across months and years. Researchers can compare themes, phrases and units in dated recordings to see which parts persisted or changed. The timing and location of both recordings matter.
Is song heard only on breeding grounds?
It is most closely associated with breeding, but scientists have recorded it along migration routes and in feeding areas. The northern British Columbia study is one example of detections outside well-known low-latitude breeding grounds.
Can a hydrophone recording identify the individual singer?
The recording may establish that song was present. Identifying an individual generally requires other evidence that links the sound to a particular whale. A separate visual identification can help when researchers have enough information to connect it to the sound.
