Back to the journal

What Humpback Flipper Slaps, Tail Slaps and Breaches May Mean

Humpback flipper breaking the water at a distance

A humpback breach is a leap in which a substantial part of the body rises out of the water and falls back. In a flipper slap, one or both long pectoral fins strike the surface. In a tail slap, the flukes come down against the water. Each movement can produce a splash and sound, and studies of migrating humpbacks suggest that some of these movements play a role in communication. The setting matters. A single breach or slap leaves the whale’s motivation uncertain, even if the movement itself is clear. NOAA Hawaiian Islands Humpback Whale National Marine Sanctuary behaviour guide Kavanagh and colleagues, study of humpback surface behaviour

Off Campbell River, you may turn towards a splash after the movement has ended. Look at the surrounding water for another surfacing. If a long flipper rises and comes down on the next pass, you have a specific movement to describe. The original splash could have come from the same whale or from a different movement nearby. Note what you saw before trying to join the two events.

Identify the part of the whale that moved

A breach can show much of the whale’s head, back or flank above the water. A humpback may turn in the air, and its landing can create a broad splash. From the side, a clear view can show the body leaving the water. From farther away, the splash can obscure much of the animal. If you saw a flipper and part of the side without seeing how the body rose, keep that limit in your notes. The size of the splash gives little information about which part struck the surface.

A flipper slap often gives you a narrower object to watch. A humpback may roll and raise a long pectoral fin, then bring it down. You may see the whale’s side or another fin as it shifts. If the fin repeats the movement from roughly the same position, the sequence can be easier to identify than the first slap. A pectoral fin extends from the side of the body. Its narrow, elongated outline can help distinguish it from the wider paired lobes of the tail.

A tail slap involves the flukes striking the water. A fluke raised for a dive can look similar for a moment. Watch what happens next. During a dive the tail may slide away as the whale descends. During a slap the flukes make a forceful contact and disturb the surface. Another movement researchers record involves a more extensive swing of the tail stock, the part of the body leading into the flukes. If the base of the tail was hidden, describing the flukes and the strike is more reliable than assigning a technical name to the entire movement. Humpback behavioural observation study

What a splash can communicate

A body or fin hitting the water makes sound as well as spray. A whale near the surface can create a signal that other animals may hear underwater. Researchers have asked whether some surface movements help whales communicate within a group or with other groups at a distance. To test that idea, they compare when movements happen with factors such as the position of neighbouring whales, changes in group composition and the conditions at the surface.

In one study of migrating humpbacks, breaching was less likely when the nearest other group was within four kilometres than when it was farther away. The authors proposed a possible role in communication between more distant groups. They also found some slapping behaviours associated with changes in groups. These are patterns across observations. A whale close to others can still breach, and a whale in a similar position can behave differently during another observation. The study gives a reason to consider communication without assigning a fixed meaning to a breach off British Columbia.

You can use the same logic on a smaller scale. If a whale slaps the surface several times and another whale changes direction, record the order, distance and what each animal did. It is possible that the events were related. The second animal could also have been responding to prey, another whale or something you couldn’t see. An observer can describe the sequence while leaving the relationship open.

Wind and waves change what observers detect

A humpback can use sound underwater as well as sounds created at the surface. In a study of migrating whales, researchers found that as wind-driven background noise and sea conditions increased, the whales’ recorded signals shifted towards more sounds from surface activity relative to vocal signals. The result concerns the conditions and whales in that study. It illustrates how the usefulness and form of an acoustic signal can depend on the surrounding water and noise. Dunlop and colleagues, research on wind-driven noise and humpback communication

The view from shore changes too. A large breach may stand out even in rough water. A low surfacing, small flipper strike or gentle roll can be hard to distinguish in the same waves. If you record more breaches during a windy watch, consider both what the whale did and which movements were easy for you to notice. A wider comparison needs time spent looking, visibility and other information about the encounters.

Wind also carries sound through the air differently depending on your position. You may hear a sound clearly from one side of a channel and miss it from another. An underwater microphone and a person on shore record different parts of the event. One can detect sounds transmitted through water, while the other may be able to connect a visible body movement with a splash. Studies that combine methods can examine the connection more closely.

Read the sequence before interpreting it

Suppose a humpback rises with its mouth open near a patch of feeding birds, then rolls and shows a long flipper. You may be seeing a feeding sequence. The position of the flipper could be part of the turn, and the spray from the lunge may hide whether the fin struck the water. A second flipper raised and brought down deliberately enough to see the contact can give a clearer observation of a slap. Recording the sequence is more informative than labelling all large splashes in the area as breaches.

Now picture a humpback lifting its tail in smooth water. The flukes come up, the whale arches and the tail slips below the surface. That is consistent with a fluke-up dive. If the flukes lift and hit the surface several times without the animal descending in the same way, record repeated tail slaps. A single view of a tail held above water might precede either action. The next few seconds tell you how the movement ended.

Changes around the whale can help explain why researchers look at behaviour in context. Another whale may join the group, a group may split or the animals may change direction. Keep the time of each event and the number of animals you could see. When the water or your angle hid another part of the group, note that limit. A clear description of three actions in order helps someone interpret the encounter more than a single word describing what the whale seemed to feel.

What to make of repeated actions

A series of slaps can help identify the body part making contact. It can also show the spacing of movements. If the whale raises one flipper and lowers it three times, you have a record of repetition. If two whales are close, you may see one fin on each side and have trouble deciding which whale made each splash. A wide frame can preserve the arrangement of animals before you zoom in on a single movement.

Repetition can make an event more visible without explaining its purpose. You might see several slaps with the whale in the same place, followed by a dive. A researcher would look for other sequences with similar conditions and compare how often the behaviour occurred. One sequence is evidence of the movements you saw. A repeated pattern across encounters can support a broader interpretation.

You can keep the same distinction in a caption. “Humpback rolled and struck the water three times with its left flipper” describes the observation. If the side was uncertain, say “one flipper.” If a companion saw another animal nearby, add the approximate location and whether it was visible throughout. A description that another watcher could recognise is useful even when the function remains unknown.

How to record a splash you saw only at the end

Use the last place you saw the whale as a reference. If the splash hid the whole animal, describe the direction from your viewpoint and whether a fin, back or tail appeared in the next moments. A short video can preserve which part of the body came into view after the water began to fall. The frame that looks most dramatic may show only spray. A frame a moment earlier or later may show the actual contact. Keep the wider recording if it shows the direction of travel or another whale.

Now imagine you hear one sharp impact and turn to see a second splash. Write down both observations. The first was a sound from an uncertain source and the second was a movement you may be able to identify. If you later learn that a companion saw the full body emerge at the first impact, that gives you a separate account of a possible breach. Compare times and landmarks before combining them.

Researchers make similar distinctions when they classify surface activities. Their protocols define the movements and report how they observed them. A study with a good view of the body can classify an event more precisely than a record of sound alone. For a visitor, “large splash, body part unseen” is a useful category that leaves room for better evidence.

Watch from a position that leaves the whales room

From a public shore viewpoint, use a landmark to keep track of where a splash occurred. On a boat, stay in the position the crew directs and let the skipper manage the vessel. Keep the surrounding water in view, as another whale may surface away from the first splash. Follow current Fisheries and Oceans Canada guidance when watching marine mammals. An encounter can end after one movement or continue with several, and either provides something worth observing. DFO marine mammal viewing guidance

Eagle Eye Adventures’ Campbell River whale watching tour gives you a chance to compare what you see with a guide’s account when whales are encountered. A guide can help you identify the fin or body part that produced a splash and describe whether other animals were present. Behaviours and sightings vary. Eagle Eye Adventures also has an article about watching humpbacks safely for readers who want context on seeing a large whale from shore or a boat.

Does a breach tell you how a whale feels?

A breach tells you that the whale propelled much of its body out of the water. It can have several possible functions, and the surroundings help researchers test which explanations fit. A nearby group, wind and the sequence before or after the movement are worth noting. A short encounter can leave much of that context hidden. You can describe a breach confidently when you saw it clearly and keep any explanation as tentative as the evidence warrants.