Back to the journal

How to Use a Whale Identification Catalogue Without Overstating a Match

Field notebook and photo catalogue workspace without legible markings

Start a whale catalogue comparison by identifying the species and the part of the animal your photograph shows. Look for a reference image taken from a comparable angle. Compare the outline and several distinctive markings, then check whether other catalogue entries fit the same features. If the picture hides a decisive mark, keep the identification provisional and share the original photograph with the relevant research programme. A catalogue entry can suggest a strong candidate without resolving what the photograph leaves out. Fisheries and Oceans Canada humpback whale catalogue Marine Education and Research Society photo contribution guidance

Suppose you photographed a humpback off Campbell River and one catalogue image looks familiar at first glance. Before you write a name under your photo, compare the visible trailing edge, the pattern across both sides of the fluke and any persistent marks you can see. Then try the same test on another plausible whale. The comparison should give you a reason to prefer one candidate and an account of any detail that remains hidden.

Choose the catalogue that covers your question

A photo catalogue has a scope. It may cover one species, a particular region, one population or a defined period of fieldwork. Fisheries and Oceans Canada has published catalogues for different Pacific killer whale groups, including Bigg’s killer whales from coastal British Columbia and adjacent waters. The Canadian Pacific Humpback Collaboration maintains a province-wide catalogue for humpbacks sighted off BC, coordinated by the Marine Education and Research Society. Start by checking the catalogue description and its date. A catalogue of the right species can still contain only a subset of the individuals you might see. DFO Bigg’s killer whale catalogue publication record Marine Education and Research Society photo contribution programme

Your first comparison can be quite simple. Does the catalogue show the part of the whale visible in your photo? Does its region make sense for the encounter? Is the publication old enough that there could be new records or newer images elsewhere? A book with clear reference images can be useful alongside a newer research database. Write down which one you used so someone looking at your notes can find the same entry.

If you’re still deciding which species you photographed, work on that first. A general wildlife guide can help you compare a dorsal fin, tail or body shape before you look for an individual. Eagle Eye Adventures’ guide to marine life around Campbell River introduces species you may encounter in the same waters. A regional guide helps narrow the species. A photo catalogue asks a finer question about which individual matches the image.

Put the same surfaces side by side

A humpback fluke catalogue typically shows the underside of the tail, including the pattern and trailing edge. The top of the tail can look quite different and may lack the marks the catalogue uses. For killer whales, published catalogues frequently use the dorsal fin and the saddle patch immediately behind it. Check whether the reference shows the same side of the body as your photo. A notch that appears on one edge may look different when the body turns, and pigmentation can differ between sides. DFO northern resident killer whale catalogue

Match the angle as closely as you can. A fluke held sideways can make one lobe look shorter. Water can conceal the bottom edge of a dorsal fin or reflect a light stripe across the saddle. A clear image of the whole fluke is easier to compare than a picture where the tip vanishes in foam. If you have a short sequence, look for the frame that best matches the reference angle. Keep the preceding and following frames because they can help confirm which marks are real and whether the photo shows the left or right side.

Use simple adjustments for comparison, such as zooming and making a crop from a copy. Keep the original frame and its metadata. A tight crop can hide the direction of travel, other animals in the frame or the waterline that explains why part of a mark was missing. If the original photo is dim, adjusting brightness on a copy may help you inspect it. Any difference that only appears after a strong edit is worth treating with care.

Find more than one feature that agrees

Start with the main shape, then locate smaller marks relative to that shape. A white area on a fluke is more useful when you can describe where it sits, whether it touches an edge and what surrounds it. A notch on a dorsal fin can carry more weight if a second mark in the same position also agrees. For each clue, ask how clearly it appears in your photo and whether it is distinctive enough to separate candidates.

A rough comparison can become stronger when you use landmarks. On a humpback fluke, line up the centre and outer tips before comparing marks. If an indentation falls close to the centre in your photo and near the tip in the reference, that difference deserves attention. On an orca, compare the shape and position of the saddle patch in relation to the fin. A pale area farther back may still be a reflection or a different feature. DFO northern resident killer whale catalogue

Distinguish a conflicting mark from a hidden one. If the reference has a conspicuous notch and your clear, comparable image shows a smooth edge in the same place, the mismatch matters. If water hides that part of the edge, your image offers no way to check it. A hidden feature should remain open in your notes. This is especially important when one candidate looks familiar and you’re tempted to explain away every difference.

Compare a competing candidate

Search for another entry that shares the broad outline or colour pattern. Look at both without focusing on the name, nickname or places each whale was previously reported. If you only compare your photo with your first suggestion, almost every matching detail can seem decisive. A second candidate shows which marks are common within the set and which features may actually separate the two.

Imagine you have one mostly dark fluke with a pale patch near the centre. Two catalogue images show a similar amount of white. In the first, the pale mark reaches the edge on the left lobe. In the second, it remains separated from the edge by a dark strip. If your photograph shows that portion clearly, you have a specific comparison to make. If spray covers it, the broad colour remains consistent with both. You can name two candidates in a submission and explain which frame would be needed to distinguish them.

Location and timing can help you decide which catalogue to check. They can also help a researcher interpret a match after the visible marks agree. Whales move, and a documented individual may appear far from a place it was previously recorded. The absence of a recent local record may reflect the area’s survey coverage. Let a clear morphological comparison carry most of the identification, with geography as context.

Keep a separate record of photo quality

An image can be excellent for showing the whale species and poor for identifying the individual. A sharp wide shot may show that several animals were present while their fins are too small to compare. A frame with only part of a tail can preserve a useful mark for later work. Describe the limitation alongside the file rather than deciding the photograph has no value. Researchers can sometimes combine views from the same encounter.

Check whether successive frames show the same whale. If you photographed two animals surfacing together, one may supply a clear saddle patch and the other a distinctive fin. The two features become misleading if you assign them to one whale. A wide frame, timestamp and order of surfacings can help you reconstruct which animal appears in each close frame. If you can’t tell, submit the sequence with that uncertainty.

A catalogue image can have its own limitations. It may be older, taken from a different side or show only one pose. Some marks can change over time as animals acquire new scars or injuries. A later photo may show an additional mark while the earlier outline and pattern still agree. When the difference matters, look for other dated views or leave the decision to the catalogue team. The date of a reference image is part of the evidence.

What an automated suggestion can and cannot settle

Some research programmes use photo comparison tools to help find possible matches. A suggested result gives you an entry to examine. Read what the programme says about the scope of its records and how it handles matches. If an image has only one fluke lobe or a fin partly hidden by water, inspect the part the suggestion seems to rely on. A result that appears at the top of a list still needs visible evidence, particularly if the same broad shape appears on several whales. The original image lets a reviewer assess quality and check the surrounding frames.

If you see no candidate you can support, record that the image yielded no match in the catalogue you searched. That describes a result of the search. There may be a reference photo in another collection, a newer edition or a view of the other side that would resolve the comparison. A new individual can also be added only through the relevant research programme’s process. A failed search on one image is insufficient to establish a new individual.

A useful comparison note names the catalogue, date and candidate ID, then records one feature that agreed and one feature that was hidden or different. For example, a later frame might show that a pale line in the first image was foam. If it disappears with the wave and the underlying pattern becomes visible, use the clearer view. The revised note should make it easy to tell why your assessment changed.

Share a useful tentative identification

A submission can include the original photo, date, general location, direction of travel if known and any related frames. Follow the research programme’s form or instructions. In your description, give the species, the potential catalogue entry and the exact features that match. If the reference has a feature you could not check, say which part of the image was hidden. “Possible match, centre pattern agrees and outer right edge is covered by foam” gives a reviewer more to work with than “definitely this whale.” MERS guidance for contributing humpback whale data

After a programme reviews the photo, you can add the determination to your record. Keep the earlier notes if they explain why you initially reached a different view. A reviewer may know about newer photographs or candidates absent from the edition you used. If a team cannot confirm the individual, the sighting can still document the species, date and approximate area.

While taking photographs, follow the crew’s directions on a boat and current marine mammal viewing guidance. An incomplete photograph is worth more than a better angle obtained by disturbing the whale. Wait for the view the animal gives you. If you see a back or fin for only a moment, you can still record the encounter, preserve the images and leave the individual’s identity open. DFO marine mammal viewing guidance