Back to the journal

How to Read a Marine Wildlife Population Trend Chart

Wide coastal ocean with distant whale surfacings

To read a marine wildlife population trend chart, first identify the animals, area and years covered. Then check whether each point is a direct count, an estimated abundance, a sightings index or a model result. Look at uncertainty and changes in survey methods before comparing the points. A rising line can reflect more animals, better detection, broader coverage or a combination of these factors. British Columbia’s resident killer whale census records and offshore cetacean survey estimates illustrate two ways of measuring populations that require different readings. COSEWIC killer whale assessment and population trends DFO 2018 Pacific cetacean abundance survey

If you’re reading about a species you saw near Campbell River, it can be tempting to look for the most recent number first. Start instead with the title, caption and the names on the axes. A total for one identified population and a count of animals seen in a survey area can both be accurate. They can also tell very different stories about what is happening along the coast.

Check which animals the chart covers

A species can contain several populations with different histories. Canada’s 2023 killer whale status assessment includes distinct trends for Northern and Southern Resident killer whales. Figure 9 shows their trajectories over several decades and identifies the sources for each line. The lines refer to specific populations, with different last years shown. A result for one population tells you about that population even when the animals in both lines belong to the same species.

Other charts refer to a geographic survey area rather than a defined population of known individuals. A survey may estimate how many animals were in a group of coastal waters during a season. Whales that spend time outside those waters are beyond the area measured, even if they use the surveyed coast at other times. The caption should tell you whether the result describes a biological population, animals within a geographic area, or a more specific group such as mature individuals.

Eagle Eye Adventures’ overview of orca populations around the world provides a broader geographic comparison. When using any published figures, keep the date, source and population next to the number. A dated count in a Canadian assessment is useful for the period it covers. For a more recent count, look for the latest release from the research programme and check the definition it uses.

Find the unit on the vertical axis

A chart can show the number of individuals researchers identified, estimated abundance, a rate of sightings per unit of effort or an index. An index tracks a measure related to abundance on a defined scale. For example, groups seen per hour of searching can help compare observations when the protocol is consistent. It does not directly give the number of individuals in the population. If the vertical axis is a percentage, look for the baseline or denominator before treating the line as a count.

Counts based on individual identification can have particularly clear meaning when researchers have long histories for the animals. A photo-identification census can use recurring photographs to track known killer whales. The COSEWIC assessment also explains how incomplete coverage affects some estimates, such as when not all matrilines were seen in a year. A census total or best estimate should be read with any notes about animals missed, births and deaths, and the dates of the survey.

A ship-based line transect survey works differently. Observers follow planned routes and record detections, and researchers estimate abundance for the area using methods that account for how animals are detected. The estimate may include corrections for animals that were diving and unavailable to observers. DFO’s 2018 Pacific survey describes the routes, species, strata and assumptions behind its estimates. The values represent estimated numbers in the surveyed region at the time, rather than the number of individual photographs a team matched. DFO science advisory report on abundance and distribution in Canadian Pacific waters in 2018

Read the uncertainty with each estimate

A point on a graph often represents the study’s best estimate. Bars or a shaded band may show an interval. Check the caption to see whether it is a confidence interval, credible interval, observed range or another measure. An interval describes uncertainty under the method used. It is useful information about how precisely the study could estimate the quantity. A wide interval can make a modest apparent change difficult to distinguish from uncertainty in the estimates.

For a concrete example, a DFO comparison of inshore fin whale abundance discussed a lower estimate from the 2018 survey than from an earlier study of the same strata. The confidence intervals were wide, and the authors reported that the estimates were not statistically different. That conclusion is stronger than a quick visual comparison of the central points because it addresses uncertainty explicitly. The report also notes that uncertainty limited its ability to detect trends.

Overlapping intervals are a reason to check the analysis, rather than a universal test of whether two points differ. Different studies may use different designs or share information across years. If the researchers fitted a trend, look at the reported trend estimate and its uncertainty. A line drawn through central values can help you see the pattern. The analysis tells you how confidently the study can distinguish it from variability or limited detection.

Compare like with like across years

Check the survey region, season and method for every period you compare. Expanding a study from inshore waters to a larger area can add animals to an estimate because it covers more habitat. Moving the survey to a different month can change how many migratory animals are in the area. Changing equipment or observation methods can affect which animals are detectable. If the paper supplies a comparison using the same geographic strata and approach, use that comparison for a trend question.

Watch for gaps in the horizontal axis. A graph can connect the last point before a gap to the first one after it. The line makes a visual connection without showing observations in the intervening years. Some charts estimate values for missing years or show a fitted trend, and the caption should explain how that was done. Read the dots and the line separately if the chart uses both.

For seasonal wildlife, time windows can be even more important than dates alone. A summer estimate and an autumn estimate in the same region can describe different groups of animals moving through. A chart showing one survey from each of several summers asks a different question from one summarising observations in all seasons. If a year is labelled by publication date, check the methods for the fieldwork dates before comparing it with another report.

Choose a time period that fits the question

Two readers can look at the same series and describe different changes if they choose different endpoints. The COSEWIC chart for Southern Residents shows periods of increase and decline. A comparison starting near a peak will differ from one starting near an earlier low point. Both can describe their intervals accurately. State the dates and whether you are describing change between two points or the longer pattern across repeated measurements.

The scale of the axes can also change the appearance of the trend. If the vertical axis starts well above zero, small changes can look steep. A wider time range can make them look flatter. Read the numbers, and check whether the axis uses equal steps or a logarithmic scale. When the chart has several panels, verify that they use the same vertical scale before comparing the slopes by eye.

Consider the difference between a change in number and a percentage. In an invented example, a rise from 50 to 60 is ten animals and a 20 percent increase. A rise from 500 to 510 is also ten animals, and it is a two percent increase. Keep the starting value with the percentage. If a report quotes a rate per year, check whether it is an annual trend fitted across the series or an average inferred from the endpoints.

Distinguish a past estimate from a future projection

Some charts extend beyond the last year of observed data. The later line may show a projection based on assumptions about future survival, births or threats. Check where the observations end and the projection begins. The caption may give several possible trajectories under different conditions. If a model explores what happens when prey availability changes, the result describes the model’s response to that assumption. It should be read as a conditional estimate. The COSEWIC killer whale report discusses population viability analyses separately from its charts of historical population sizes.

The uncertainty around projections can increase farther into the future. The amount depends on the model and what the plotted band represents. Check whether the band reflects sampling uncertainty, differences among scenarios or both. A chart can also show a central trajectory even when the authors are primarily concerned with the range of possible outcomes. To summarise that figure, name the scenario and period along with the direction of the projected change.

Check whether all ages are included

A total population can change while the number of mature animals follows a different pattern. The 2023 killer whale assessment discusses periods when juvenile recruitment and the number of mature animals changed by different amounts. A chart of all individuals can therefore give a different impression from a chart of adults capable of breeding. If you want to understand why the two lines differ, check which age groups were included and how the research programme classified them. A calf documented during a survey can appear in the total while contributing nothing to a count of mature individuals. The two series can then respond at different times as that animal ages, even if both records are accurate.

What the chart leaves to other evidence

A population curve can describe a change without identifying its cause. Births, deaths and movements can affect counts or estimated abundance. Researchers may use demographic records, information about prey, health data or other evidence to investigate causes. Those findings can accompany a trend chart, but they come from analyses that answer more than how the line changed. A graph that rises after a management action gives a chronology. Evidence about the effect of the action needs a way to assess other changes during the same period.

A flat line also deserves care. It might describe a population with little change or a study that could not detect a change at the scale measured. Check the interval, length of the series and authors’ conclusion. If a report uses the word “stable,” read how it defines it and which period it refers to. An assessment can describe relative stability in one region while leaving uncertainty about smaller areas or shorter intervals.

A concise summary should name the animals, place, period, measure and strength of the evidence. For example, “the estimated abundance in these inshore areas was lower in the later survey, and the study could not distinguish the estimates statistically” preserves more information than “the whales declined.” If you can give that kind of account after reading the title, legend, methods and conclusion, you can use the chart without asking it to answer a question outside its scope.