Back to the journal

How Sea Otters Change Kelp Forests

A sea otter floating in a coastal kelp bed, realistic natural history scene

Sea otters eat sea urchins. Sea urchins graze on kelp. Where otters reduce the density of urchins on a reef, kelp can face less grazing pressure and grow into a denser forest. Ecologists call this a trophic cascade because a change at one level of the food web affects other levels. Long-term reef surveys off western Vancouver Island have documented strong links among otters, urchins and giant kelp. The strength and speed of the response vary with the conditions on the reef. Long-term kelp forest study in western Vancouver Island and California

You can picture the process by starting at the bottom. On a rocky reef, kelp grows attached to the substrate while urchins feed nearby. A sea otter diving into that habitat may bring an urchin to the surface to eat. Multiply that kind of predation across many days and animals and the reef may support fewer grazers. Kelp has a better chance to grow if there is suitable rock, enough light and tolerable water conditions. The surface canopy people see from shore or a boat is one part of the outcome.

Why the urchin matters

An urchin is a grazer with a real effect on the vegetation around it. When many urchins feed on a rocky reef, they can limit the kelp that grows there. Some rocky areas with persistent grazing and little large kelp are called urchin barrens. The term describes a contrast in the vegetation and community. A barren still contains living organisms, including the grazing animals that help maintain the state. An expanse of rock can therefore belong to a functioning ecosystem even where tall kelp is scarce.

The interaction can start with a young kelp. Kelp has microscopic stages that are invisible during an ordinary dive or a walk along the shore. A young kelp needs to survive long enough to grow blades and rise away from the bottom. If repeated grazing removes young growth, the canopy can remain sparse even when rock and light are suitable. An otter’s effect on the grazer can thus change what grows above it. The connection is indirect because the otter eats the urchin and the urchin affects the kelp.

There is also a timing difference between a change in urchins and a visible change in kelp. Grazers can decline before new kelp establishes and grows enough for an observer to notice. An existing canopy may decline after waves damage it or conditions interfere with recruitment. A snapshot taken in one season gives you the condition of the reef on that visit. A series of surveys gives you a chance to see the order in which changes occur.

What researchers saw off western Vancouver Island

Researchers have revisited rocky reef sites on western Vancouver Island over many years and compared them with kelp forests in California. They examined changing densities of sea otters, sea urchins and kelp. Off western Vancouver Island, there was a strong association between more otters and fewer urchins, and urchins and kelp tended to show opposing patterns. The relationship was less uniform in the California data. The comparison matters because it shows the same broad food-web connection playing out differently in different regions.

It helps to think about what the researchers were counting. A diver can count urchins and look at the extent or density of kelp below the surface. A survey team can also observe where otters occur. When researchers repeat those observations in the same places, they can ask whether an area gained kelp after urchins declined, and whether another reef nearby behaved differently. The study covers places and dates where surveys were conducted. The results give a mechanism to consider in other places, with local data needed to know its strength there.

Other work off western Vancouver Island has examined what that change means for rockfish. Researchers compared giant kelp forests in areas with and without sea otters and looked at how fish related to the habitat. This extends the question beyond whether a canopy is visible. If kelp becomes more abundant or grows in parts of a reef where it was previously scarce, the underwater spaces available to fish change too. Which fish use those spaces depends on the species, its life stage and the place being studied. Study of indirect sea otter effects on rockfish

Kelp changes the shape of a reef

Rock and crevices already give reef animals physical structure. Kelp adds more of it above the bottom. Large blades and stalks fill part of the water column, while holdfasts attach kelp to the substrate. A patch of small kelp near the bottom presents a different habitat from a tall canopy. Fish can move among the blades and through open areas between kelps. The additional structure matters because animals of different sizes can use it in different ways.

From above, floating blades can mark where the taller part of a bed reaches the surface. Lower-growing kelps and algae in deeper water can be much harder to see. A surface boundary can shift as the tide or current pulls the blades to one side. An apparent gap may show where a canopy failed to reach the surface, where there is different substrate, or where kelp is genuinely sparse. Mapping the forest in a way that supports comparison requires more information than the colour and outline of the surface patch.

When a piece of kelp breaks away, it can drift beyond the reef where it grew. A mass of kelp on a beach records where material washed up, and that material can come from somewhere else. Similarly, a single otter resting over the canopy records an otter in that patch of water. It takes repeated observations and a view of the bottom to link the animal to changes on the reef. Keep those different views in mind when you encounter an apparently simple picture of kelp, otters and the coast.

Why two nearby reefs can look different

Even where sea otters occur, water depth and clarity affect the light available to kelp. Wave exposure can influence whether a kelp bed persists after storms. Rocky substrate provides places for holdfasts to attach, whereas mobile sand offers different growing conditions. The history of grazing and the species of urchins present also matter. A place can experience strong otter predation and still have stretches where kelp growth is limited by other conditions.

Consider two rocky points in the same area. One has a dense canopy above a shallow ledge and the other has a few isolated blades above deeper rock. If you compare them from shore, the first looks like a better example of a kelp forest. Your comparison also mixes depth, exposure and viewing angle. Seeing an otter off one point would add information about where that animal was. It would take measurements of kelp and urchins and more than one visit to assess the relationship between otters and the difference in vegetation.

Changes can run in both directions through time. Predation may open space for kelp, and stronger grazing or an unfavourable growing period can contribute to a loss of canopy. A long record lets researchers look beyond an unusually good or bad year. It also helps distinguish a persistent difference between reefs from a temporary change in either place. Those distinctions explain why a study that compares regions, sites and years can give a richer answer than a single coast-wide statement about sea otters.

Follow the cascade in the order it happens

One way to test your understanding is to imagine a reef where otters start feeding regularly. An early survey might show more otters and roughly the same kelp cover as before. A later survey might show fewer urchins without a canopy yet. Given suitable conditions, a survey after another growing season might show more kelp. At each visit, a different step in the chain would be visible. If you looked only at the first two visits, you might conclude the kelp hadn’t responded. If you looked only at the last visit, you could miss the change in grazers that makes the response plausible.

Now consider a second reef with a similar change in urchins and no increase in canopy. That difference opens questions about depth, light, the available substrate and the remaining grazers. You can also ask whether the second reef had time to respond, and whether changes in kelp appeared below the surface where the canopy could not show them. Comparing those two cases is more informative than expecting the second reef to follow the first on the same schedule. It also helps explain why the researchers report variation within regions as well as contrasts between them.

What a visitor can observe

If there’s kelp visible from a safe public viewpoint, trace the outline of the surface canopy and then look at the shoreline. Is there a rocky point beside it? Do the blades line up with the flow of water? Does the surface patch look continuous or broken into smaller areas? These observations describe the part of the habitat you can see. Even with clear water, individual urchins may be too far down or too small to pick out. You can leave their density as an open question.

If you see an otter, pay attention to whether it is diving, floating or moving along the shore. A coastal otter sighting could also involve a river otter, which readily uses salt water. The animal’s body posture, tail and hind feet can give you more information than its location. Observe from where you are and let the animal continue what it was doing. The Canadian sea otter assessment describes how the two species differ. COSEWIC sea otter assessment

The western Vancouver Island studies give readers a real example of this process in British Columbia. A kelp bed you see around Campbell River can still prompt the same questions about bottom habitat, water flow and grazing. Local conditions and the animals using the area deserve their own observations. Eagle Eye Adventures’ guide to Campbell River wildlife beyond whales introduces other coastal animals to look for while you’re watching the water and shoreline.

What does a single otter sighting tell you about kelp?

It tells you where one animal was while you were watching. If you see it bring an urchin to the surface and eat it, you also have a direct observation of feeding. To infer what that predation does to a reef, you’d need to know how often it happens, how many urchins remain, how kelp responds and what else is changing. A single feeding observation is still a useful way to connect a process you can watch to a question researchers answer with a longer record.

If you return to the same shore later, you can compare what is visible under roughly similar viewing conditions. A fixed landmark gives you a useful reference for the edge of a canopy. Note the date and water conditions and keep the comparison to what you saw. “The floating blades were visible farther around the point in August” is a description that someone else could check. “Otters caused the bed to grow” would require evidence about the otters, urchins and reef over time. That difference is what makes the food-web research so valuable when you try to interpret a changing coastline.