Humpback whales bubble-net feed by releasing air underwater as they swim, creating a curtain of bubbles around or near a patch of prey. One whale may make and use a net alone, or several humpbacks may take part in a coordinated feeding event. The bubbles can help keep small fish or krill concentrated for a lunge. What you see from a boat is often the end of the sequence, when bubbles reach the surface and a whale rises with an open mouth. Research off British Columbia and Southeast Alaska helps explain what happens below the surface and why a ring of bubbles by itself is only one clue.
The net starts beneath the surface
A bubble net takes shape as a whale releases air while following a path around prey. The movement of the whale helps determine where the bubbles are released. The bubbles rise, creating a curtain in the water. The target is a patch of prey that the whale can engulf along with a mouthful of water. Underwater footage, aerial views and motion measurements let scientists relate the whale’s path to the ring observers might see from above. Study of solitary bubble-net feeding in Southeast Alaska
The shape visible on the surface is a partial record. Water moves, the bubbles take time to rise and the animal continues swimming beneath them. A neat circle in a video may make the process look like a simple manoeuvre at the surface. The whale may have made the net while moving through several depths. In the Southeast Alaska study, scientists examined the three-dimensional tracks of whales using nets on krill. That evidence helped them ask how the animals adjusted the way they made nets.
A net is also temporary. Bubbles rise and disperse. Each lunge takes place in a changing patch of water and prey. If you are watching a series of photographs, look for how the net developed before the whale surfaced. The timing can be more informative than the shape of the last visible bubbles. A single photograph of a mouth and a foam patch usually captures too little of the sequence to explain what the whale did underwater.
How bubbles help concentrate a meal
A humpback feeds by taking in prey and water, then retaining prey with its baleen while the water leaves the mouth. The concentration of the prey matters because each lunge involves effort and the mouth contains a limited volume. A whale that can keep more prey within reach may take in more food in a single feeding event. Bubble-net studies examine how whales achieve this with different prey and in different conditions. NOAA humpback whale profile
The word net describes the way the bubble curtain affects prey. A fishing net holds animals with a physical mesh. Bubbles can influence where prey go without creating a barrier made of material that a whale can retrieve. Different prey can respond differently, and the shape or timing of the bubbles can matter. A well-placed net gives the whale a more concentrated patch to lunge through. It takes field measurements to estimate how much that changes feeding success.
After the lunge, the whale still needs to filter and swallow its food. This is the part in which baleen does the work that a visitor may associate with the idea of a filter. The bubble net works outside the body before the mouth takes in the prey and water. The baleen works inside the mouth after engulfment. Thinking about those two stages helps explain why a whale can use bubbles to improve its catch while relying on its anatomy to finish the meal.
Solo feeding can happen in a crowded area
Researchers in Southeast Alaska documented humpbacks making bubble nets while feeding individually on krill. Some were in an area with many other whales. The number of whales present and the number using any one net are different observations. A group of animals feeding near one another may include whales each making a separate net. If you are reading a sighting description, check whether it describes an aggregation of whales or several animals coordinating around the same prey.
Consider a scene with three visible rings. One whale lunges in the first ring, then another appears in a separate ring farther away. Their movements may have happened within seconds of each other. The spacing and the separate use of each ring would be useful details to record. If several animals rise tightly together through one area in a repeated sequence, the observation would raise a different question about how their actions are related. Observers need enough of the sequence to choose between those interpretations.
Solitary feeding also gives researchers a way to examine how one animal builds a net. They can relate movements recorded by a tag to what they see from the air. Where a group is involved, the task includes working out which whale released bubbles and how the others positioned themselves. A visitor who sees only the surface may be able to describe the result without seeing who produced every part of it.
How a coordinated feeding event is documented
A recent Canadian Pacific study describes both cooperative and solo bubble-net feeding. In the group behaviour it examined, researchers describe a feeding call and a coordinated event around prey. A feeding call documented during group foraging is distinct from the long structured song associated with male humpbacks. A person watching from above the water may see several whales rise together and have no acoustic evidence from below. Study of cooperative and solo bubble-net feeding in Canadian Pacific waters
The coordinated lunge can be the clearest part of the event from a distance. Several mouths may break the surface near one another. Position, direction of movement and the timing of each whale’s surfacing all help researchers describe the group’s actions. A sound recording, when available, can provide information that a video alone cannot. Interpreting distinct roles calls for observations that connect particular actions to particular whales.
The same Canadian study investigated whether the spread of the behaviour among identified animals was associated with their social connections. That is a question about how a feeding practice spreads over time. The study uses encounter histories, including occasions when individual whales were first seen doing the behaviour. An individual may have learned or performed it before observers documented it. The dates are best read as dates in the observation record.
Read a sighting in the order things happened
Start with the water before the lunge. Did a ring or organised line of bubbles appear? Were small fish visible near the surface or was prey inferred? Look at where the whale surfaced relative to the bubbles. If you saw the same sequence several times, note what repeated. These details give a guide more to work with than a description that begins and ends with an open mouth.
Bird activity can be another clue that prey is near the surface. A flock diving around a patch of water does not establish that a whale produced a net. Birds can respond to fish concentrated for several reasons, including the actions of other predators. Likewise, disturbed water can appear after a lunge. The order helps you distinguish bubbles that preceded the whale’s arrival from foam produced as an animal surfaced.
There are also other humpback feeding methods. A whale can lunge without a bubble net. Researchers have documented a separate feeding behaviour called trap feeding in British Columbia, in which the whale can remain relatively stationary at the surface with its mouth open. An open mouth is therefore only one feature to look at. Movement before and during the event helps tell you which explanation fits.
Keep the view you have on a Campbell River trip
If humpbacks are feeding, watch a broad patch of water from the position the crew provides. A boat may be unable to see the start of an event, especially when the whale is submerged. From a distance you may still notice that bubbles appeared first or that several whales came up together. The guide can describe the possibilities and explain which evidence is visible. Follow their viewing instructions and let the whale’s movement determine what you get to see. DFO marine mammal viewing guidance
A wider photograph can be more useful than a tightly cropped mouth. It can preserve the position of the ring, the other whales or the nearby birds. If you make a video, a few seconds before and after the lunge can provide context for the scene. Keep the date and approximate location with your notes. For a personal trip journal, describe what you actually saw and record the guide’s interpretation separately if the behaviour was uncertain. Eagle Eye’s guide to wildlife seen on a whale watching tour
Bubble-net feeding is an opportunity to learn about the ecology of a day on the water. It is one possible encounter among many. When you plan a tour, choose the time and duration that suit your group and leave the itinerary open to local conditions. If a feeding whale is seen, ask what signs the guide used to distinguish the technique. Eagle Eye’s Campbell River whale watching tour
How scientists follow a net from two viewpoints
A camera above the water can record how bubbles spread and where the whale surfaces. In the Southeast Alaska study, records from devices temporarily attached to whales provided another perspective. Motion data helped the team reconstruct how the animal moved and footage supplied information from near the whale. Combining those views gave researchers more detail about how and where each net developed. Neither viewpoint alone provided all of the information needed for the reconstruction.
A view from above also helps distinguish between a surface pattern and the process that produced it. By the time a full ring is visible, some bubbles may have travelled farther than others. The whale could already be moving toward the concentrated prey. When researchers relate the arrival of the bubbles to the animal’s path, they can ask how timing affects the feeding sequence.
In a published result, check how the team determined which prey was present and whether it measured the net or estimated part of its form. Observations from one prey type and location can explain the mechanism for those encounters. They also give scientists a basis for testing whether whales use the same approach under different conditions. An example can establish that the behaviour occurs without showing how common it is across the coast.
Frequently asked questions
Can one humpback bubble-net feed by itself?
Yes. Researchers have documented individual humpbacks making and using their own bubble nets. Southeast Alaska research describes solo nets used to feed on krill. Canadian Pacific records also include solo feeding.
Does every visible bubble ring come from bubble-net feeding?
A bubble ring can be a useful clue. Check the sequence, the location of the lunge and whether you saw prey or repeated behaviour. A report that contains only a ring does not establish how the bubbles were made or used.
What do humpbacks catch when they bubble-net feed?
Documented examples include krill and small schooling fish. Prey and foraging conditions vary by place. Look at the study’s location and how the researchers identified the prey before applying an example to another encounter.
Can I tell which whale made the bubbles in a group?
You might see which whales surfaced and how they were positioned. Establishing which made the bubbles usually requires a clearer view of the underwater sequence or supporting research evidence. If the beginning was hidden, describe the visible part of the encounter and leave the individual roles open.
